New York Times
- September 12, 1999
article > Graham
Fuller
source > Harmony
Special K
link > nytimes.com
NEW YORK -- Cinema history is punctuated by the work of visionary
mavericks who will go to any lengths to get their films made, and
who require their collaborators to share their obsessive dreams.
Erich von Stroheim, who subjected his crew to misery during the
filming of the climactic scenes of Greed [1924] in
blistering temperatures in Death Valley, boasted, "I was
going to metamorphose the 'movies' into an art -- a composite of
all arts. Fight for it! And die for it, if need be! Well, fight I
did. And die I almost did, too!"
Stroheim was matched in brinkmanship by Werner Herzog, who not
only decided to make the documentary La Soufriere [1977] on
the Guadeloupe Volcano after hearing it was about to erupt, but
allegedly made his star, Klaus Kinski, work at gunpoint during the
filming of Aguirre, The Wrath Of God [1972] in the Peruvian
Jungle. Returning to the Amazon for Fitzcarraldo [1982]
Herzog echoed the fanatical quest of the film's main character by
hiring hundreds of Indians to pull a steamship over a mountain.
Several were killed during production.
The latest would - be member of this club is Harmony Korine, the
young, prodigiously talented writer of Kids [1995] and
writer - director of Gummo [1997] and julien donkey -
boy, which will be shown at the New York Film Festival before
its October 15 release. While Korine took his cameras into some
squalid situations -- most notably a cockroach - infested house --
during the filming of Gummo, he has yet to lay his life on
the line in the same way his friend and mentor Herzog has done.
Yet he aspires to -- or at least did so until a few months ago.
"For the longest time I was willing to die for film," he
said in an interview. "When I make a film, it consumes me to
such a degree that it feels it's my only purpose for living. My
relationships are damaged, I don't know how to tie my shoes and I
can't make my bed. Or I can, but I don't think about these things,
and my life suffers because of that."
Actress Chloe Sevigny agreed: "He's a miserable wreck when
he's not working." Ms. Sevigny, who is Korine's girlfriend
and has known him since both were 17, is a regular in his films.
"Harmony's always going to need other people around to look
after him," she said.
One reason Korine is no longer willing to kill himself for his
work is his experience making a film he has now abandoned. So
slight he looks about 18 despite the wispy beard sprouting from
his chin. Korine, who is 25, had himself videotaped fighting
strangers on the streets of Manhattan. "I wanted to make a
cross between a Buster Keaton film and a snuff film," he said.
"My intention was to fight every demographic, but I fought a
bouncer who broke my ankle and three ribs, and I got arrested
three times. It was starting to get painful, and then my mother
found out and got really worried. So I promised her I'd go see a
shrink, which I did."
Korine acknowledged that he had been behaving self - destructively.
"This was during a period when I was losing my mind," he
said. "I'm now beginning to regain it a bit. It was maybe a
way of punishing myself for something. I am now trying to find
some kind of medium between making the movies I need to make and
surviving as a human being." During Korine's childhood, much
of it spent in the Appalachians. His father, Sol, was an itinerant
documentary filmmaker whose interests ranged from circus clowns to
moonshiners. Korine eventually went to live with his grandmother,
Joyce Korine, in Queens, New York City. [Her house is the setting
for julien donkey - boy. Korine attended New York
University as an English major, quitting after one semester. A
meeting with photographer Larry Clark led to his writing, at the
age of 18 and in three weeks, the script for Kids, Clark's
controversial 1995 film about promiscuous teenagers.
After another script he wrote for Clark was shelved, Korine
directed Gummo in the Tennessee environs of his youth. That
tale of two adolescent cat killers was not only a simultaneously
ugly and beautiful antidote to Hollywood narrative structures; it
was also Korine's first excursion into what he calls a new film
grammar, a kaleidoscopic mix of realistic and surrealistic scenes
not necessarily connected to one another. "After 100 years,
films should be getting really complicated," he said. "The
novel has been reborn about 400 times, but it's like cinema is
stuck in the birth canal."
julien donkey - boy, a more mature [if not less graphic]
film than Gummo is the harrowing story of a paranoid
schizophrenic that was inspired by Korine's uncle, a long -term
patient at the Creedmoor Psychiatric Center in Queens. Without so
much as a story, the movie simply follows Julien around: From the
opening sequence, in which he kills a little boy, through the time
he spends in an institute for the blind, to the streets, a skating
rink, and so on. Korine had wanted to make a film about his uncle
for some time. "Greta Garbo had a schizophrenic uncle named
Cromwell," he cryptically wrote in his 1998 novel, A
Crackup At The Race Riots an abstruse collection of musings
that painted an ironic portrait of life at its most whimsically
quotidian and spiritually bleak.
Julien, the film's tormented protagonist, who reveals an
affectionate nature during his moments of lucidity, lives
dysfunctionally with his ranting father, his dreamy pregnant
sister, his brother, who fancies himself a wrestler, and his
silent grandmother. The father is played by Herzog, the sister by
Ms. Sevigny, the brother by the newcomer Evan Neumann and grandma
by Joyce Korine. Julien is played by Scottish actor Ewen Bremner,
who prepared for the role by visiting Korine's uncle in Creedmoor
and working in a hospital for six weeks. "His portrayal of
Julien was so intense," said Ms. Sevigny, "That I can no
longer talk to Ewen as Ewen."
Korine claims that had Bremner overidentified with his role and
lost his bearings, it would have been in a good cause. "I
knew the film would be fake if, when I said 'Cut,' Ewen had said,
'Can I have a cappuccino now?' If Ewen had lost his mind forever,
I would be sad, but at the same time it would have been worth it.
I demand everything from the people I make my films with. I demand
their blood."
Of course, he made this troubling statement safe in the knowledge
that Bremner had survived with his faculties intact. And he
admitted that he had been relieved when the shoot was over. One
cannot help thinking, however, of the British prisoner of war,
played by Michael Bryant in the BBC drama series Colditz,
who persuaded his commanding officer to let him feign madness to
secure his release under international law. The soldier succeeded
only too well: He went insane in the attempt, leaving his officer
full of regret.
Bremner got the role of Julien after Korine abandoned the idea of
casting his institutionalized uncle or another schizophrenic or
even himself. The actor was not scarred, he said, either by his
immersion in the character or by his director's compulsiveness.
"Harmony's not by any stretch of the imagination an easygoing
guy or a perfect citizen," Bremner said. "But one of the
things I respect about him is that he's fearless. He's not going
to pull any punches in the way he goes about making his films. He
uses what he's got -- his fear, his love and his pain -- but he
never allows any of that to get in the way. Nothing does, really."
Far from thinking Korine callous, Bremner has paid him tribute by
calling his newborn daughter Harmony. "My partner chose the
name," Bremner said. "I thought she was joking when she
suggested it. It's not to do with the film particularly, but
simply because Harmony is inspiring."
Korine's fervent approach to filmmaking was outlined in his
confession to the Dogme collective of Danish directors, including
Lars Von Trier and Thomas Vinterberg, who in 1995 issued a
manifesto of rules to counter "the film of illusion" and
"personal taste."
In submitting julien donkey - boy for the group's seal of
approval, Korine wrote: "If I was ever to make a 'western,'
for instance, and a horse died because I asked too much from the
stallion, I would not shed a tear simply because it died by my
command. I would weep only if the horse died off camera. Cinema
sustains life. It captures death in its progress. Thus the horse
dies for the world as did Christ himself."
The Dogme brethren must film with hand - held cameras on location
and eschew unnatural light, optical work, produced sound, music,
superficial action, props not found on the locations and the cult
of the director. Largely obedient to this creed, julien donkey
- boy broke a few of the commandments: For example, Ms.
Sevigny was not truly pregnant [Korine confessed in his statement
that he had not had time to impregnate her before filming began].
The fine distinctions between what does and does not make a Dogme
film may be forgotten in the dismay that Korine's film is likely
to engender. Like Gummo, which Janet Maslin reviled in her New
York Times review as "the worst film of the year,"
and "An aimless vision of Midwestern teenage anomie, complete
with drugs, garbage, dead cats and neat tricks like turning off
Granny's respirator." julien donkey - boy is a
pullulating collage of images that many will find unpalatable: A
Thalidomide - maimed man playing the drums with drumsticks held
between his toes; blind people demonstrating that you really have
to be able to see to go bowling; Julien yowling in various states
of degradation, and scenes involving a fetus.
To dismiss these images as grotesque or exploitative, though,
would be to misinterpret Korine's intentions. The characters have
been filmed neither patronizingly nor with voyeuristic relish, but
with tenderness and humour.
There is the same overarching humanity in the film that Tod
Browning brought to his circus sideshow performers in Freaks
[1932] or Herzog to the midget cast of Even Dwarfs Started
Small [1970].
"I think it would be a worse kind of discrimination not to
use people because of the way they look or because of their
handicap or their strangeness," said Korine. "You can
show Tom Hanks stuttering or Dustin Hoffman doing his 'Rain Man'
thing and they win Oscars for playing cute, lovable mentally
insane people. That makes me angry, because as soon as you show
someone screaming with fear at the voices they hear in their heads,
puking on themselves or punching themselves in the face, it
becomes 'exploitation.' But to me it becomes something meaningful."
Korine cites the films of Jean - Luc Godard, British director Alan
Clarke, who died in 1990, and Herzog among his influences. The
drive to make uncompromising movies at any cost is clearly part of
the affinity between him and Herzog.
"Harmony's original intention to play my son in his film was
metaphorical, of course," said Herzog. What does he think of
Korine's aesthetic?
"When I saw a piece of fried bacon fixed to the bathroom wall
in Gummo, it knocked me off my chair. He's a very clear
voice of a generation of filmmakers that is taking a new position.
It's not going to dominate world cinema, but so what?"
Korine's self - dramatizing zeal for art over life borders more on
the naive than the unconscionable. Less messianic in person than
his take - no - prisoners stance would suggest, he is a gifted
filmmaker with a disturbing world view and infectious passion. In
a movie environment clogged with opportunists and journeymen, he
is much needed.
Perhaps Vinterberg best summed him up when he said: "Harmony
has a haunting relationship to his filmmaking, which is creating
almost a mythology around his work. I believe it's a matter of
life or death for him. Everybody who's involved with a certain
serious level of emotional life on screen has that kind of
experience, but whereas others struggle to have a life next to
their films, I think Harmony gave in."
Copyright 1999 The New York Times
Company. All rights reserved.
|